Challenges, workarounds if husband represents himself in Loudoun County murder trial

When Roger Paul Bradford announced to a Loudoun County substitute judge Wednesday that he intended to represent himself against second-degree murder and firearms charges in the death of his wife, the judge said he had that right, but advised against it.

“The Supreme Court, in a case called Faretta versus California, found that a criminal defendant has a constitutional right to represent himself during trial,” said Alexandria-based attorney Steven Webster, in a WTOP interview.

“But first, the court has to explain the disadvantages and risks of that choice.”

Webster is not involved in Bradford’s case.

Bradford is charged in the Sept. 22 death of his wife, Lisa, in their Aldie, Virginia, home.

During his first appearance in Juvenile and Domestic Relations District Court, Bradford told substitute judge Kelly King several times that he plans to represent himself, and that he generally distrusts lawyers.

King warned Bradford about several extemporaneous comments, including “I don’t want a bond hearing — I’m right where I need to be,” and that he is hopeful the case can move forward quickly, “for my children.”

Despite Bradford’s declaration that he wants to represent himself, King set an Oct. 21 counsel review date, in the event Bradford decided to hire an attorney or request a public defender.

“First, the court will warn the defendant that he’ll have to follow the same rules of procedure and rules of evidence that attorneys do,” Webster said. He expects the judge will also explain, “The prosecution will have a big advantage because of their education and trial experience, and that the defendant will not be able to claim after the trial that he was ineffective in representing himself.”

However, once the court determines a defendant’s choice to represent himself is knowingly and voluntarily made, “No one can force a defendant to be represented by a lawyer,” Webster said.

Bradford’s wariness of lawyers was not discussed in detail during his brief appearance, but as WTOP previously reported, in 2023 Bradford was sentenced to 20 months in prison, plus three years of unsupervised release after pleading guilty in Iowa to conspiracy to commit wire fraud in connection with a kickback and bid-fixing scheme involving construction contracts.

Possibility of standby counsel

Webster said even when a defendant chooses to, and is allowed to represent himself, judges frequently appoint standby counsel.

“Standby counsel is a lawyer who will sit through the trial and help with routine advice on procedure, the rules of evidence, and other courtroom protocol and decorum,” Webster said. “But the lawyers can’t try the case like they normally would — they can only give advice.”

In court filings regarding his Iowa conviction, Bradford described his ongoing challenges with mental illness, which became exacerbated as the couple headed toward divorce. During his incarceration, he said he was often suicidal.

“My marriage with my wife Lisa is now headed to divorce as the pressures and injustice of this nightmare took its toll on our marriage and our life together,” he wrote.

“The fact that my X-year marriage to this incredible woman is likely coming to an end is too much to bear.”

A defense attorney might ask a judge to order a psychiatric evaluation.

“There’s a difference between competency to stand trial and competence to represent yourself,” Webster said. “Competency to stand trial is always required.”

However, if Bradford represents himself, it’s unclear whether, or how effectively, he would address his own mental health.

“Competency to represent yourself is not required,” Webster said. “A defendant does not need to be competent in the sense that he’ll adequately represent himself, and most likely, he will not.”

Source